This is one of the early classic narratives by a senior commanding general of the Confederate armies. Uninventive, legalistic and bitter, the work is a great disappointment. Miscommunication and distrust characterized the developing relationship between Johnston and Davis in the spring of The estimates of troops involved in various battles are way off, typically underestimating the Confederate numbers and overestimating those of the Union. A few errors appear.
Wilson and the Yalobusha River. Events are sometimes confused, too, such as several incidents during the Vicksburg Campaign.
Separated by chronology and illustrated with pertinent maps, the papers cover a wide range of important subjects and campaigns. The Robert E.
In short, the papers allow readers to discover the real Lee unclouded by the embellishment of admiring biographers and presented clearly for anyone interested in independently interpreting his actions and recorded thoughts. It is unfortunate that this work is poorly annotated, which to a degree limits its usefulness as a significant research device. Despite that, all students of the war should relish this invaluable companion. His explanation of Gettysburg includes charges made by various officers and refutations of those charges, countercharges by other generals and refutations of the countercharges.
It tells the story of the war in first person from one of the great generals of American history, allows him to make his case and at least on some accounts quiets the armchair strategists who over the years have faulted Long street too severely. In the main, Longstreet is correct with most of his assertions, and the well-documented inflation of the Lee side of the Gettysburg controversy can be traced through the pages of the Southern Historical Society Papers and elsewhere.www.emanuellive.com/wp-content/samsung-s8-mini-takip-1.php
Stonewall Jackson, Used
Longstreet here provides ample documentation of his close relationship with Lee, although his language is sometimes blunt and egotistical. Moderately successful in his West Point Class of , the North Carolinian was commissioned colonel of the 3rd North Carolina at the outbreak of war and rose to major general before his death. Fearless and outstanding at Seven Pines, Cedar Mountain, Sharpsburg, Fredericksburg and Chancellorsville, Pender was struck by a shell fragment on the second day at Gettysburg.
He ignored his leg wound long enough for infection to set in, and he did not survive the subsequent amputation. They contain gossip and musings but also much of military interest. His observations of Lee, Jackson, A. Hill and D. Hill are valuable and add significantly to the body of work on the Army of Northern Virginia. The editor of this volume might have annotated the letters in a significant and helpful way; that notwithstanding, it is still an excellent book.
The son of Zachary Taylor, brother-in-law of Jefferson Davis and a lieutenant general in the Confederate Army, Taylor was in a unique position from which to observe events both military and political during the war.
Along the way Taylor interjects valuable commentary on various military operations and how they unfolded. Despite his connections with Davis, Taylor delivers an objective treatment of many individuals who were not so well connected, including Joseph E. In a reflective chapter following a description of surrender, Taylor subtly blames Longstreet for the loss at Gettysburg, laments over the lost opportunity of Shiloh and writes that if any single individual could have saved the cause of the South, it was the commander killed at that battle: General Albert Sidney Johnston.
So there you have it. The greatest memoirs and letters by Confederate generals offer a mixture of mostly outstanding material but also much rationalization and spreading of blame. We have the intensely interesting, behind-the-scenes looks at other officers by Porter Alexander. Early offers great anti-Yankee fanaticism blended with his recollections of the war. Gordon gives us a fascinating view of several important battles and an exaggerated account of his own story. From Hood we get attacks on others, along with an attempt to substantially boost his shattered reputation.
From Lee we get critically important correspondence from the field that forms a central core of knowledge about the Army of Northern Virginia. Longstreet leaves readers with an assault on his critics that washes over numerous pages. From Pender we get enthralling observations of his superiors that make for outstanding reading. Taylor, finally, provides excellent analysis, with a particular focus on the Western theater. These books are all good. But to enjoy and understand them, you need to know the angles the authors were playing.
He admits the utter defeat of the South and looks forward to peaceful race relations. Like other Northern writers, he lays much blame not on the South as a whole but on Jefferson Davis. Unrepentant about secession and yet respectful to the Union, A Rebel's Recollections works toward reconciliation, even as it overlooks more brutal and contentious aspects of the war.
One would think war horrible enough without the monstrous exaggerations that seem inseparable from the story of it. Nothing is more common than to hear and read about "mowing down" the enemy or being mown down by them, projectiles cutting "wide gaps" through charging columns, "heaps of slain" that clog the cannon wheels, "rivers of blood" and the rest of it. All this is absurd: nothing of the kind occurs—nothing, rather, of the degree.
These are phenomena of the campfire, the hearthstone, the "rostrum" and the writing-desk. They are subjective—deeds of memory in a frame of mind. They have a fine literary effect when skillfully employed, and in purely literary work are allowable in landscape painting to aggrandize the mountains.
Outside of literature their use is to humbug the civilian, frighten the children and grapple the women's hearts with hooks of steel—all tending to the magnification of the narrator. Like Eggleston, other common soldiers found opportunities to publish their memoirs. Privates and sergeants received occasional space in Battles and Leaders of the Civil War. Others published pieces in newspapers and magazines, including James P. Some of the war's most evocative and most critical depictions came from Ambrose Bierce, who reprinted many of his war memoirs in his Collected Works ; also in A Sole Survivor: Bits of Autobiography, Bierce entered the Union army as a private and left as a first lieutenant.
He witnessed some of the war's most furious fighting and later wrote such classic short stories as "Chickamauga" and "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" Like his fiction, Bierce's memoirs are polished performances that yet reveal the horrors of the war—eviscerations, burned corpses, brain fragments, even pigs feeding on the faces of the dead. Ironic and caustic, Bierce understands how the war is romanticized and sanitized by memory, even as he sometimes falls prey and knows he falls prey to the cheerful temptations of nostalgia.
Yet for all the common soldiers who wrote about the war for family, self, and posterity, relatively few published their memoirs between and One explanation for this is that prominent generals commanded larger audiences and had more access to publishers. Only in the twentieth century did many "bottom-up" recollections appear in their entirety. A Virginian on Stonewall Jackson 's staff, Douglas — disapproved of slavery but fought for the Confederacy. His memoirs paint a complex picture of Jackson—capable of great tenderness and violence, fearless as well as God-fearing. Another interesting memoir, this time from a Yankee, is Alfred Bellard's d.
The New Jersey —born Bellard enlisted as a private in the Army of the Potomac, and his memoirs including rough sketches and drawings focus on his day-to-day life as a soldier—marches, weather, work details, food, accommodations, and battles. Reflecting the boredom, complaints, and cynicism that could mark the life of a soldier, Bellard's memoirs give an unromantic, revealing picture of the war.
Another perspective on the war focuses on African American soldiers. Not allowed in the Union military until , almost , black troops enlisted in the Union cause while a lesser number served or were conscripted on the Confederate side. As David W. Blight has shown, the presence of blacks in the Civil War was often "whitewashed" away in the decades that followed, in part because conflicts over racial equality remained an obstacle to national reunion. But if many postwar Americans sought intersectional harmony at the expense of black rights, others memorialized African American contributions during the war.
One such figure was the white abolitionist Thomas Wentworth Higginson — , whose Army Life in a Black Regiment details his experiences commanding African American military units. Higginson's regiment was composed of ex-slaves freed by Union forces. At a time when Northerners debated whether blacks should be allowed in the military, Higginson's First South Carolina Volunteers vindicated the abilities of black soldiers.
In Army Life in a Black Regiment, Higginson describes his men as disciplined, intelligent, honest, and—most important—courageous. Like most white Americans of the time, abolitionists included, Higginson engages in some racial stereotyping. But while he often depicts his men as naturally musical and childlike, he also attends to the cultural conditions that shaped their lives under slavery.
Higginson's memoirs insist upon the potential of African Americans as citizens. By looking back on the Civil War, he fights for black rights in the postwar period. The same is true of other war accounts written by African Americans. Of particular interest was the renowned Massachusetts Fifty-fourth, a black regiment that suffered massive casualties in its assault on Fort Wagner, thus demonstrating to the nation and world the mettle of African American soldiers. Though not precisely a soldier, Susie King Taylor b.
Taylor was stationed in South Carolina near Higginson, who wrote an introduction to her book. Her narrative is sparse but also remarkable, detailing her escape from slavery into Union lines, her dedication to her "boys," her learning to shoot, and her resourcefulness in caring for the wounded and hungry.
Taylor ends her memoirs with a chapter titled "Thoughts on Present Conditions," making explicit her call for racial equality and assailing those Americans who refused to fulfill the egalitarian promises of the war. The broader cultural desire to ignore black rights, coupled with educational and economic disadvantages, can help to explain the relative dearth of Civil War memoirs published by African Americans between and The Civil War is traditionally associated with military forces.
Civil War Memoirs
But as scholars such as Elizabeth Young, Kathleen Diffley, and Drew Faust have shown, the experiences of women and men on the home front are no less compelling. For Americans not directly involved in the fighting, the war affected family members, domestic arrangements, and entire worldviews.
- Gabriels Journey (Evan Gabriel Trilogy)!
- What the Students Taught the Teacher (About Suzuki Series).
- Book Reviews (2);
- In Tune: Charley Patton, Jimmie Rodgers, and the Roots of American Music.
Noncombatants provided material support and ideological direction to various war efforts. Civic unrest and the return of the wounded brought the war home to many Americans. With battles raging on native soil and with news spread quickly by voice, print, and image, the war changed the lives of many civilians, some of whom wrote their memoirs. From a Southern perspective, Kate Stone's Brokenburn: The Journal of Kate Stone, — reprints her writings from the war and its aftermath, revealing the anger, anxieties, and privations Stone — endured on her family's Louisiana plantation before fleeing into Texas to escape the Union army.
Stone's narrative traces a dramatic arc—from initial optimism, to utter despair, to a homecoming and a final acceptance of defeat. Along the way Stone describes such traumatic events as the deaths of two brothers, an uprising of slaves, and the destruction of her childhood world. Most famously, Mary Boykin Chesnut 's — memoirs show the war as seen—and reconstructed—by a South Carolina woman married to a prominent Southern politician.
Chesnut kept journals of her wartime experiences later published as The Private Mary Chesnut, Her memoirs first appeared as A Diary from Dixie , a text presented as a day-to-day diary but one that Chesnut wrote in the early s by revising her earlier journals. The complicated composition history of A Diary from Dixie shows how memories of the war are under constant revision. Chesnut's book is also a fascinating portrait of a witty, willful, and complex woman who disliked slavery but supported the Confederacy, was simultaneously inspired and disabled by the war, and found both a solace and a burden in the writing of her wartime experiences.
Keckley c. Her book is part slave narrative and part memoir, mixing fiction with historical fact while gossiping about famous war figures and, more intimately, their wives. Showing the cruelty and generosity of both Northern and Southern whites, Behind the Scenes is an antislavery book that yet appeals to national reconciliation.
Keckley's careful use of symbol and voice also suggests that while blacks and women were often forced behind the scenes, they nonetheless played powerful roles in the war, a point made more explicitly in Frederick Douglass 's autobiography, Life and Times of Frederick Douglass , expanded The most notable memoir from a noncombatant may be Walt Whitman 's Specimen Days , an autobiography that recounts among other things his work in Union hospitals.
Like many of his generation, Whitman — calls the Civil War "the distinguishing event of my time" p. He describes the horrors of the hospital—groans and blood, despairing deaths, wagons full with amputated limbs. Yet as in his book of Civil War poems, Drum-Taps , Whitman finds heroism and wholeness in the war without denying its destructive effects. Based on Whitman's wartime journals, Specimen Days is a visionary but also grounded effort to find in the grim realities of the war a vindication of America's indestructible potential for unity, freedom, and compassion, all represented, Whitman suggests, in his own personal largesse.
Finally, another major literary figure who looks back on the war is Mark Twain — , whose "Private History of a Campaign That Failed" simultaneously satirizes and participates in the genre of Civil War memoirs. Published in Century Magazine during the heyday of its memoir series and appearing after Twain was criticized for profiting from the dead Grant's Personal Memoirs, Twain's "Private History" begins by noting the rage for Civil War heroes only to present his own wartime experience as someone who "didn't do anything" p.
In his fictionalized story, Twain and his teenage friends are swayed by romantic views of the war, but their laughable efforts to form a military company show that they lack the skill and will to take part in the conflict. It is only after they ostensibly kill an innocent stranger that they learn the true magnitude of the Civil War.
That tragedy erupts in the comic plot indicates how hard it was in the postwar period to romanticize the war. And that Twain and his Missouri company barely dodge, allegedly, an engagement with the young Grant shows how close the war came to many Americans, even those who lived through it as a private affair. Grant ; Reconstruction. Bierce, Ambrose. Collected Works. New York : Neale, Cave, Robert Catlett. Edited by Walbrook Swank. Shippensburg, Pa.
Eggleston, George Cary. A Rebel's Recollections. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, Grant, Ulysses S. Personal Memoirs of U. New York : Penguin Books, Lincoln, Abraham. Speeches and Letters. Edited by Peter Parish. London: Everyman's Library, Sherman, William Tecumseh. Memoirs of General W. New York: Library of America, Twain, Mark Samuel Clemens.
New York: Penguin Books, Whitman, Walt.
Complete Poetry and Collected Prose. Aaron, Daniel. New York: Knopf, Ayers, Edward. Ithaca, N. Berlin, Ira, Joseph P. Reidy, and Leslie S.
Jackson Middle Summer Reading - Jackson Ms
Rowland, eds. Cambridge, U. Blight, David W.
Related The Memoirs of Stonewall Jackson [annotated]
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved